Sunday, December 14, 2014

Two Years to Nowhere

Two Years After Newtown, Mental Health Still Matters, and Most People Still Don't Care

"On the first day of Christmas, my true love gave to me..."
This weekend, on the second anniversary of the Newtown shootings, I took my daughter to see her first performance of the Nutcracker. Unsure of the exact venue, we parked on the street and followed the hordes of blond girls dressed just like my daughter in velvet dresses with satin sashes. I have wanted to reenact this holiday tradition from my childhood with my own now 9-year old for many years. But this year was the first time we could actually go together. Two years ago, her brother was in an acute care psychiatric hospital, and I shared our painful story with the world. A year ago, she was with her father, who talked a judge into giving him full custody by arguing that the younger two children were not safe in a home with their brother. Mental illness affects more than  the individual: it affects the whole family.

This year, two years after Newtown, our family is stable, happy, spending the holiday season the way we imagine families in Hallmark cards spend it: decorating our tree, wrapping presents, drinking hot cocoa, and making up new lyrics to “The 12 Days of Christmas.” But we know how fragile, precious, and rare this gift of Christmas present is.

What changed for my family in the two years since Newtown? One word: treatment. Before Newtown, I was afraid to speak up and demand help for my son. After Newtown, in large part because I shared our family’s private tragedy, my son, unlike Adam Lanza, got the help he needed. A diagnosis of bipolar disorder does not “fix” all the challenges my son and our family still face: after years of maladaptive coping strategies, he—and we—are learning a new normal, where we ask for help when we need it. And we still struggle, as many families do, with access to care. But we have what so many other families still lack: hope.

In the immediate aftermath of Newtown, I felt tremendous optimism that people finally cared and understood about mental illness. Sadly, I was wrong. The simple changes—earlier interventions, more access to care, more support in the school system, day treatment crisis centers—have not materialized. We continue to blame parents—and children—for behavioral symptoms of brain disorders. Worst of all, we continue to sentence people to jail or relegate them to homelessness because of their illness.

Along with other mental health advocates, I’ve watched the responses to the tragic deaths of Michael Brown and Eric Garner with considerable sympathy. People with mental illness, no matter what their race, also face challenges with law enforcement officers, especially in cities where police lack Crisis Intervention Team training. Here is a partial list of people with documented mental illness who were killed by on-duty police officers in 2014:
Here's an idea! We could send an ambulance on mental
health calls, like Norway does. 
  1. Keith Vidal had documented schizophrenia. When his family called 9-1-1 for help with a behavioral episode, the police shot and killed the 90-pound 18 year old. 
  2. Parminder Singh Shergill, a U.S. Army veteran who suffered from PTSD, was shot and killed by police after his mother called and asked for medical help. He lunged at officers with a knife. 
  3. James Boyd, a homeless man with mental illness, was shot and killed in a confrontation with Albuquerque police. 
  4. Matthew Pollow had schizophrenia. He lunged at the police with a screwdriver and was shot and killed. 
  5. A woman in Santa Clara called police to say she was suicidal. When she answered the door holding a baseball bat, they shot and killed her. 
  6. Dontre Hamilton, who had schizophrenia, was shot and killed by Milwaukee police in a confrontation. 
  7. David Latham, who likely had schizophrenia and had been off his medications for a few days, was shot and killed by Virginia police when his aunt called 911 to ask police to help him. 
  8. Jason Harrison, who had schizophrenia, was killed when his mother called the Dallas police to ask for medical help for her son. 
  9. Nick Davis, who had schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, was shot and killed by police when he swung at them with a crowbar. 
  10. Rosendo Gino Rodriguez was killed by police in Midland, Texas when he retreated to his room during a welfare check initiated by his family. 
  11. Michelle Cusseaux was shot and killed by Phoenix police who were tasked with taking her to a mental health facility on an emergency hold. 
  12. Kajieme Powell, a St. Louis man with mental illness, charged police yelling “Shoot me now!” They did, just days after Michael Brown’s death in nearby Ferguson. 
  13. Chelsea Fresh, who suffered from bipolar disorder, was shot and killed by police in Beaverton, Oregon. She was holding a rifle. 
  14. Calvin Peters, a Brooklyn man who had bipolar disorder, was shot and killed after he stabbed a student in the face. 
  15. Thomas Read was shot and killed in New Jersey when he came at police with a knife. He had schizophrenia and had been unable to get his medications because of a problem with his health insurance.
This list is not exhaustive: it’s hard to track how many people are killed by police each year and whether those killings are justified. And the problem works both ways. Just as people with mental illness are killed by police, law enforcement also faces threats: Mental Illness has tracked 115 deaths of police officers since 2009 that can be attributed to people with untreated mental illness. 

I should stress here that people with serious mental illness are not likely to be more violent than people in the general population, unless they are untreated. Without treatment, the risk of violence to self and others rises. That has certainly been my experience with my own son. Once we had a correct diagnosis and medications that worked, the threats of harm to self and others stopped. I don’t believe that medication alone is the answer—talk therapy and occupational therapy are extremely important in helping my son to navigate a world that presents him with significant sensory challenges. But lithium changed everything for my son and my family.

I think often of the Newtown families, the pain of that first Christmas without loved ones, of gifts wrapped for children who would never open them, of holes left in hearts that will never fill. And I also think of Adam Lanza and his mother and wish for all our sakes that he could have gotten treatment before tragedy. That’s my wish for every family who struggles with the often overwhelming challenges of mental illness. But we can’t do it alone. We need the support of our friends and communities. We need society to stop blaming us and our children. But most importantly, we need access to care. Without treatment, two years after Newtown, for too many families, Christmas is a time of sorrow and loss and grief. 


vabna islam said...

This post is really informative to all kind of people. I am very happy to see the post. I will request you to give more information about this. I have gotten many knowladable speech form here. I have also website where you can get some knowledge which may be for your welfare. Visit here…..
true love

JanetDavies said...

Thank you for continuing to speak up for our mentally ill kids, Liza. I am joining you in raising my voice, in telling our story and advocating for mothers and their mentally ill children.
I know I should be grateful that my adult son who has schizophrenia is still alive after an assault he committed during an untreated psychotic break but I am terrified and angry. I am terrified at how serious that illness can be and infuriated that there is no help no matter how hard we tried.
How many people is it okay to lose? How many more ruined lives are an acceptable price to pay so we can bury our heads in the sand, point fingers at exhausted, desperate mothers and gun control? Anything but face what we can't completely understand, something that is unseen and that frightens us.

It makes me happy to see your beautiful family enjoying the holidays together and I wish you all much joy!

Alex's mom said...

As always, thank you Liza for giving us a voice. Let's hope for a better future in which our children will be safer, from themselves and others who are supposed to protect and defend. Every morning I say a silent (prayer? I don't really pray) that my son will survive the day in this society. I was happy to hear from you on my email account, I have gotten out of FB because there is just too much pain there amongst the cute puppies and such. Enjoy the holidays with your family, you are all special.

Eric said...

Thank you for sharing your story. I was made aware about the problem the mental illness patients face when dealing with police during the Kelly Thomas trail here in Southern California. Kelly Thomas (April 5, 1974 – July 10, 2011) was a homeless man diagnosed with schizophrenia who lived on the streets of Fullerton, California. He was beaten and ultimately killed by Jay Cicinelli, Manuel Ramos, and Joseph Wolfe, three members of the Fullerton Police Department, on July 5, 2011. Thomas was taken to St. Jude Medical Center before being transferred to the UC Irvine Medical Center, where he was comatose on arrival and not expected to recover. He never regained consciousness, and died on July 10, 201. I prey that your Holidays are full of blessings and thank you for sharing. Your experience is helping others more than you will ever know.
Thank You.

Dvora said...

Hi Liza, how can I reach you directly?

georgeus said...

Informasi program beasiswa tanpa TEST dalam dan luar negeri bagi Mahasiswa, Dosen, Pegawai Aparatur Sipil Negara (GURU & PNS), maupun Swasta dan UMUM:
Beasiswa S1 Dalam Negeri
Beasiswa S1 UI
Beasiswa S1 UNDIP
Beasiswa S1 UGM
Beasiswa S1 UNPAD
Beasiswa S1 Luar Negeri (SINGAPURA) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $2000/bln
Beasiswa S1 Luar Negeri (MALAYSIA) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $2000/bln
Beasiswa S1 Luar Negeri (MESIR) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $2500/bln

Beasiswa S1 Luar Negeri (JPN) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $2500/bln

Beasiswa S1 Luar Negeri (AUS)+ Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $3000/bln
Beasiswa S2 Luar Negeri (AUS) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $3500/bln

Beasiswa S2 Luar Negeri (JPN) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $3500/bln
Beasiswa S2 Luar Negeri (US) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $5000/bln

Beasiswa S2 Luar Negeri (JERMAN) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $4500/bln
Beasiswa S2 Luar Negeri (INGGRIS) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $4500/bln
Beasiswa S2 Luar Negeri (PARIS) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $4500/bln
Beasiswa S2 Luar Negeri (MESIR) + Uang Saku + Biaya Hidup $3500/bln